How to Compare Promotional Merchandise Quotes Properly
Share
It's tempting to compare promotional merchandise quotes the same way you'd compare two prices at a supermarket — whichever number is lower wins. Unfortunately, this industry doesn't always make that comparison as straightforward as it should be. Two quotes that look identical on the surface can end up being very different once you dig into what's actually included, and getting caught out after you've committed is far more frustrating than taking a few extra minutes to compare properly upfront.
Why the Cheapest-Looking Quote Isn't Always the Cheapest
The headline number on a quote is only useful if you know exactly what it covers. A genuinely competitive quote and a misleadingly low one can look identical at first glance, and the difference usually only becomes clear once a formal quote or invoice lands in your inbox with extra line items attached.
Watch for Hidden Setup Costs
One of the more common issues buyers run into is a website or initial quote displaying a product price that looks complete, only for a formal quote to arrive with a separate, additional setup or artwork fee added on top. This can catch buyers off guard, particularly when comparing a headline price against a competitor whose pricing already includes setup as standard.
Before comparing two quotes, confirm explicitly whether setup, artwork and proofing costs are included in the unit price shown, or charged as a separate line item. Ask this directly if it isn't already clear — a legitimate supplier should be able to answer immediately and in writing.
Check Whether You're Actually Looking at Decorated Pricing
This is a genuinely important one to watch for: some suppliers display undecorated (blank) product pricing on their website, without making it obvious that the price shown doesn't include your logo or branding at all. You only discover the real, decorated price once you request a formal quote — at which point you've already spent time comparing a number that was never a true reflection of what you'd actually pay.
Before comparing prices between suppliers, confirm explicitly that the figure you're looking at includes decoration (your logo applied to the product), not just the blank item. If a website price seems unusually low compared to competitors for the same product, this is one of the first things worth checking.
Embroidery: Check the Stitch Count, Not Just the Price
If your branding involves embroidery, price alone doesn't tell the full story. Stitch count directly affects how much of your logo is actually reproduced and how it looks on the finished product — a lower price sometimes reflects a lower stitch count, which can mean fine detail, small text or subtle elements in your logo get simplified, merged together, or dropped entirely.
Before comparing embroidery quotes, ask what stitch count is included and whether it's sufficient to reproduce your logo accurately, particularly if your design has detailed elements. A genuinely comparable quote should specify this, not just present a flat per-unit price.
Full-Colour Digital Print: Check the Size, Not Just the Method
Similarly, "full colour digital print" sounds like a single, consistent offering, but the print area size can vary significantly between quotes at a similar price point. It's not uncommon for the cheapest quote to be based on the smallest available print size, which may not be large enough to display your logo clearly or match what you actually need.
Before comparing, confirm the exact print dimensions included in each quote, and check that this size is genuinely sufficient for your logo and branding requirements, not just the cheapest option the supplier had on hand to quote against.
Other Things Worth Confirming Before You Compare
Freight and delivery. Confirm whether delivery is included in the quoted price or added separately, and to how many locations if you need multiple delivery addresses.
GST. Check whether the quoted figure is inclusive or exclusive of GST, since this alone can create a misleading gap between two quotes that otherwise look similar.
Minimum order quantity. A lower unit price at a much higher MOQ than you actually need isn't necessarily a better deal once you calculate your true total spend.
Production timeframe. A cheaper quote with a significantly longer lead time may not be comparable at all if your event date is fixed. See our guide on Local vs Indent Promotional Products for more on how production pathway affects both price and timing.
Sample or proof availability. Confirm whether a physical sample or a detailed visual mock-up is provided before production, and whether that's included in the price or an additional cost.
Reorder pricing. If this is likely to be a repeat order, ask whether reorder pricing differs from a first-time setup, since some of the setup cost may only apply once.
A Simple Checklist for Comparing Quotes Properly
Before deciding based on price alone, confirm the following are the same across every quote you're comparing:
- Unit price includes decoration, not just the blank product
- Setup, artwork and proofing costs are clearly stated (included or separate)
- Print size or embroidery stitch count is specified and genuinely sufficient for your logo
- Freight is included or clearly costed separately
- Pricing is clearly GST inclusive or exclusive
- Minimum order quantity matches your actual requirements
- Production and delivery timeframe suits your event date
If you can tick all of these off for every quote you're comparing, you're genuinely comparing apples with apples. If you can't, the lowest number on the page may not represent the lowest number you'll actually pay.
Frequently Asked Questions About Comparing Promotional Merchandise Quotes
Why do some promotional merchandise quotes end up more expensive than the original price shown? This often happens when the original price displayed is for an undecorated product, or when setup, artwork and proofing costs are added separately once a formal quote is issued, rather than being included upfront.
What should I check when comparing embroidery pricing between suppliers? Ask for the stitch count included in each quote, since a lower price sometimes reflects a lower stitch count, which can affect how accurately your logo is reproduced.
Does "full colour digital print" mean the same thing across every quote? Not necessarily. The print area size can vary significantly between suppliers at a similar price point, so it's worth confirming the exact dimensions included rather than assuming they match.
Is the cheapest quote always the best option? Not always. A lower headline price can reflect a smaller print size, a lower embroidery stitch count, undecorated pricing, or additional costs not yet included, so it's important to confirm what's genuinely included before comparing.
What's the best way to compare multiple promotional merchandise quotes fairly? Confirm that decoration, setup costs, print size or stitch count, freight, GST treatment and minimum order quantity are all specified and comparable across each quote before making a decision based on price alone.
Already Have a Quote from Another Supplier?
If you'd like a second opinion or want us to check whether a quote you've received genuinely reflects a fair, complete price, send it through. We'll review it and, where it's a genuine like-for-like comparison, beat it.
Contact Campbell ID for a fast, obligation-free quote.